Which Cook Book
Moderator: Moderators
- Bludall
- Forum Chatterbox
- Posts: 10665
- Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 9:19 pm
- Location: East Midlands
- Has thanked: 39 times
- Been thanked: 5 times
Handyman,
I have the Mary Berry Ultimate cake book, it has over 200 classic recipes. Mary Berry does really good recipes if you follow them step by step. I usually modify them a little by added extras but they turn out really well. Delia is good but I've had the odd occasion when recipes followed pedantically have failed. I find that many of her recipes need adapting more than most.
I have the Mary Berry Ultimate cake book, it has over 200 classic recipes. Mary Berry does really good recipes if you follow them step by step. I usually modify them a little by added extras but they turn out really well. Delia is good but I've had the odd occasion when recipes followed pedantically have failed. I find that many of her recipes need adapting more than most.
Failure means you just didn't get it right yet!
Louise
Louise
-
- Deceased 21-10-2011 R.I.P
- Posts: 5945
- Joined: Fri Jan 20, 2006 6:03 pm
- Location: East of England
- Has thanked: 8 times
- Been thanked: 90 times
It's not surprising that some of Delia's recipes fail. Even by a cook who has lots of cooking experience. So what chance does a tyro have?
The ingredient lists are a bit of a mess. I just had a look at one recipe on her web site (for braised lamb with flagelot beans). Although most of the ingredients are shown in metric, it's clear the recipe was originally in imperial. Otherwise why 900g of lamb? (that's 2lb) 225g beans; 570ml water (= 1 pint)? But we still have 2 tbsp of oil. We have to guess how many ml in one of Delia's tablespoons. Same with 2 tsp of chopped thyme leaves (I wonder how you chop thyme leaves?).
I shan't bore you with the failings in the method Suffice to say that it's not Bigbird's failings that resulted in a failed dish. Where she scored was in spite of, rather than because of Delia's recipes.
The ingredient lists are a bit of a mess. I just had a look at one recipe on her web site (for braised lamb with flagelot beans). Although most of the ingredients are shown in metric, it's clear the recipe was originally in imperial. Otherwise why 900g of lamb? (that's 2lb) 225g beans; 570ml water (= 1 pint)? But we still have 2 tbsp of oil. We have to guess how many ml in one of Delia's tablespoons. Same with 2 tsp of chopped thyme leaves (I wonder how you chop thyme leaves?).
I shan't bore you with the failings in the method Suffice to say that it's not Bigbird's failings that resulted in a failed dish. Where she scored was in spite of, rather than because of Delia's recipes.
- Bludall
- Forum Chatterbox
- Posts: 10665
- Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 9:19 pm
- Location: East Midlands
- Has thanked: 39 times
- Been thanked: 5 times
Stoday,
I always think that it's a good idea to try out a new recipe as closely as possible but experience is the key to success because what one person thinks is spicy or tasty enough could be bland and tasteless to another. It's always tricky getting a happy medium.
I always think that it's a good idea to try out a new recipe as closely as possible but experience is the key to success because what one person thinks is spicy or tasty enough could be bland and tasteless to another. It's always tricky getting a happy medium.
Failure means you just didn't get it right yet!
Louise
Louise
- skiking
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3842
- Joined: Wed Sep 13, 2006 9:02 pm
- Location: Cheshire
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 4 times
I don't agree with your gripe. So what if the imperial has been converted into metric - its a measurement at the end of the day - the point is that it is consistant and proportionate to the next ingredient. Can you not chop thyme leaves ? Use a knife and place the tip on the chopping board and use a knocking motion to chop the leavesStoday wrote:It's not surprising that some of Delia's recipes fail. Even by a cook who has lots of cooking experience. So what chance does a tyro have?
The ingredient lists are a bit of a mess. I just had a look at one recipe on her web site (for braised lamb with flagelot beans). Although most of the ingredients are shown in metric, it's clear the recipe was originally in imperial. Otherwise why 900g of lamb? (that's 2lb) 225g beans; 570ml water (= 1 pint)? But we still have 2 tbsp of oil. We have to guess how many ml in one of Delia's tablespoons. Same with 2 tsp of chopped thyme leaves (I wonder how you chop thyme leaves?).
I shan't bore you with the failings in the method Suffice to say that it's not Bigbird's failings that resulted in a failed dish. Where she scored was in spite of, rather than because of Delia's recipes.
As for tbsp and tsp - its neither metric or imperial (as in 1 cup measurement in the US). I can't think on one modern book that says 5ml instead of 1 tsp.
In my mind, Delia was a pioneer in TV cooking - not great more classical.